Most of these case studies come from emails my readers send me. With their permission, I share them with the names changed. I do this so that others can learn from what worked and what didn't. Have a story of your own? Share it with me.
- 1 to 7messages a month
- 3booked shoots
- $180spent on the whole test
Eugene, Oregon, is full of bike shops, coffee roasters and boutiques that need good photos.
For two months, Anselm’s brand photographer advertising couldn’t reach a single one of them.
He’s a brand photographer who works with small, local businesses, and he had a decent ad running the whole time. It got seen.
It just didn’t get answered.
Then he rewrote it around one owner’s worry.
His brand photographer advertising went from 1 message a month to 7, and 3 of those turned into shoots.
The problem
Anselm’s work is bright and friendly. His clients say he makes their shops feel like the best version of themselves.
But his ad didn’t sound like him at all. It sounded like every other photographer’s ad in town.
He’d copied the structure from other studios’ ads, because that felt safe. Safe turned out to be invisible.
Looking back, he could see three weak spots.
What the old ad said
The headline read, “Premium brand photography packages.” The text listed three package names and a phone number.
Nothing in it mentioned a shop, a worry or a result. An owner scrolling past had no reason to stop.
What it showed
The picture was a smiling man shaking hands in a bright office.
Anselm had bought it from a stock site, because he didn’t have a client photo that felt right.
Shop owners saw the picture and thought, “That’s not my kind of place.”
Who it reached
He’d aimed the ad at the whole county, and at anyone who owned a business. That included lawyers, accountants and large companies.
Most of them were never going to hire him. The ad spent his money on people who couldn’t say yes.
The solution
Anselm didn’t need a bigger budget. He needed an ad that spoke to one kind of owner about one real worry.
He made three changes.
None of them needed new gear. They needed a clearer idea of who he was talking to.
A worry in the headline
He asked three bike shop owners what bothered them about their photos. All three said something close to the same thing.
Their photos looked like a catalog from 2009.
So his new headline said, “Your bikes are great. Your photos look like 2009.”
He tried it on two owners over coffee. One laughed out loud, which he took as a good sign.
A person in the picture
He asked a former client, a bike shop owner, if he could use a photo of her fixing a wheel.
She said yes, and she even sent him a quote.
The new picture showed real hands, real grease and a real smile.
A button that asked for less
The old button said “Book a package.” That was a big ask for a first click.
The new one said “See a bike shop gallery.” It was small, and it was easy to say yes to.
The process that worked
Anselm did the whole rewrite in two evenings and one afternoon. He didn’t hire anyone, and he spent about $180 on the test.
Evening one
He sat down with his notes from client calls and highlighted every sentence an owner had said about her photos.
Then he wrote ten headlines and picked the one that made him smile.
He also wrote down what he wouldn’t say. No “stunning,” no “authentic,” and no list of packages.
He followed the shape in four sample ads for shop owners and changed every line until it sounded like him.
Evening two
He built a short gallery page of bike shop photos, with one big picture, a few lines of text and a single button.
It echoed the ad’s headline and photo.
He added a short note under the button that said, “I reply within a day.”
He wrote the page in plain, people-first words, the way helpful content guidance describes.
The audience
On the next afternoon, he narrowed the ad to bike shops, outdoor stores and cafes within a 30 minute drive.
That cut the audience to a fraction of what it had been.
He also set the ad to show mostly in the evening, when many owners were closing up and scrolling on their phones.
He set a small daily budget and ran the old ad and the new one side by side for two weeks.
The brand photographer advertising numbers, week six
After six weeks, the old ad had brought 3 messages in total. The new one had brought 7 in a single month.
Three of those people booked shoots. Two were bike shops, and one was a coffee roaster who’d seen the ad on a friend’s phone.
What we learned from here
Brand photographer advertising works best when it speaks to one kind of owner about one real worry.
Anselm’s old ad wasn’t bad. It was general, and a general ad asks every reader to decide if it’s for her.
When he narrowed it, the right people said, “That’s me.”
| Move | Earned a message | Earned a scroll |
|---|---|---|
| Headline | A worry in the owner’s words | Premium packages |
| Picture | A real person with a real wheel | A stock handshake |
| Button | See a gallery | Book a package |
| Audience | Local shops within a short drive | Every business in the county |
| Page | One photo, one button | A page full of options |
The change also made the work easier. He no longer had to guess what to write.
He listened to owners, and he wrote down what they said.
The money mattered less than he expected. He’d spent $180, and one booked shoot paid it back many times over.
What mattered more was learning which words owners really used.
He has kept the habit. After every call, he adds a line to a notebook he calls his headline bank.
If an ad goes quiet, he asks himself three questions. Whose worry is this? Does the picture show it? Is the button small enough?
That’s usually where the problem hides.
He also keeps old ads in a folder, with notes about what they said and how they did.
Looking back every few months shows him how far his words have come.
More case studies
Gwen Started Advertising to Pregnant Moms. This Newborn Photographer Booked 14 Sessions
- 14spots booked before the babies arrived
- $32cost per booking, down from $117
- 22newborn bookings in 10 weeks, up from 6
Product Photographer Petra Cut 3 Words From Her Ad and Got 11 Messages a Month
- 2 to 11messages a month
- 5new shop clients
- $240spent on the whole test
Headshot Photographer Margot Splits 1 Ad Into 2 and Books 5 Office Teams
- 2 to 14inquiries a month
- 68people photographed for 5 teams
- $38 to $11cost per inquiry
41,000 Ad Views and 3 Inquiries. Then Portrait Photographer Calvin Got 12 Bookings
- 3 to 14inquiries a month from ads
- $160 to $22cost per inquiry
- 12portrait sessions booked
Odette’s Maternity Photographer Ads Get Rejected, Then 14 Sessions Book
- 2 to 11inquiries a month from ads
- $31 to $9cost per inquiry
- 14maternity sessions booked
7 Realtors, 1 Saturday. Personal Branding Photographer Tamara Rewrites Her Ads
- 2 to 11discovery calls a month
- 6brand sessions booked
- 7realtors in one Saturday
Brand Photographer Bertrand Fixed 3 Hot Spots on His Website and Got 11 Messages a Month
- 3 to 11form messages a month
- 5shoots booked
- 14 to 5form fields
Brand Photographer Calla Filmed Her Intro in a Taqueria and Kept 58% of Viewers
- 9% to 58%watched to the end
- 6owners mentioned the video
- 3shoots booked